Right to Use Stepfather's Surname on Child's Birth Certificate: Love Knows No DNA | Beyond Blood |

In a significant ruling, the Calcutta High Court has acknowledged the evolving realities of family structures and upheld a child's right to dignity. The court recently granted a mother's plea to replace her child's biological father's surname on the birth certificate with that of the stepfather surname. This decision recognizes the emotional bond and familial relationship established between the child and stepfather, marking a progressive step in Indian jurisprudence.

Background of the Case:

The case involved a child born from the mother's first marriage. Following the dissolution of that marriage, the mother remarried and has since lived with her current husband. The child has come to know and accept the stepfather as their father. The mother sought to formally recognize this relationship by changing the child's surname on the birth certificate to match the stepfather's surname.

Court's Observations and Decision:

Hon'ble Justice Amrita Sinha, presiding over the single bench, emphasized that personal issues with minimal public law involvement should be approached with sensitivity. The court recognized that the child identifies the stepfather as his father and that, in the absence of the requested alteration, the child might have to face embarrassing situations in the future. The court underscored that every individual has the right to live with dignity and honor .

The court also addressed the municipality's reliance on the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969, which states that once a child's name is entered in the birth certificate, it cannot be changed. The Hon'ble Court discarded the incorrigible status of the birth certificate being the divine document which can't be touched once issued. The Court clarified that the Act does allow for rectifying errors and that, due to changed circumstances, the existing entry regarding the father was improper and should be corrected. The court noted that the law was archaic and did not anticipate the present scenario.

Ultimately, the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court directed the Municipality to issue a new birth certificate for the child, incorporating the stepfather's surname .

Implications of the Ruling:

This ruling has several important implications:

Recognition of Stepfamilies: It acknowledges the validity and importance of stepfamily relationships, particularly when a child has formed a strong bond with a stepfather.

Child's Best Interest: The decision prioritizes the child's emotional well-being and right to a dignified life, free from potential confusion or embarrassment.

Evolving Interpretation of Law: The court's willingness to interpret existing laws in light of changing social realities demonstrates a progressive approach to family law.

Conclusion:

The Calcutta High Court's decision is a welcome step towards recognizing the diverse forms that families can take. It reinforces the idea that legal frameworks should adapt to reflect the evolving needs and realities of society, always keeping the child's best interests at the forefront.

Click ! below to get the judgment of Hon'ble Calcutta High Court

DOWNLOAD JUDGMENT